Market volatility hits differently when paychecks stop, and portfolio withdrawals begin. According to reporting by The Independent on a 2026 retirement study, 67% of respondents worry more about running out of money than dying, with Generation X being the most anxious group at 73%. Research from Morningstar shows that retirees who avoid investment losses in the first five years of retirement are much less likely to outlive their savings.
At the same time, data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projects that the labor force participation rate for adults aged 65 to 74 will rise from 26.7% in 2025 to 29.1% by 2035, while participation among those aged 75 and older will climb from 8.5% to 10.1%. Meanwhile, a 2026 survey by AARP found that in the past six months, 7% of retirees have unretired or reentered the labor force, with 48% citing making money as their primary reason. Despite those pressures, traditional retirement planning can still start by pitching projected market growth rather than asking how much risk a saver actually needs to take.
For Andrew Schade, a financial advisor who is rebranding his practice into an online-first platform called Swagfin, that conventional approach gets the sequence backward. Schade focuses on conservative savers who prioritize capital preservation over speculative upside. In his view, recommending stock market exposure before calculating the exact minimum return a retiree needs is like a surgeon operating before checking whether the patient requires surgery.
“Traditional advisors rarely quantify risk in plain numbers that mean something to everyday savers,” Schade says. “People do not understand alpha, beta, or standard deviations. They simply want to know they will not lose their savings.”
Conventional advisory models often default to pitching 7% to 9% projected returns because advisors are trained to sell performance, and assets-under-management fees keep incentives tied to keeping client funds invested in equities. Meanwhile, broad labels such as moderate risk fail to protect retirees once withdrawals start. Consider an illustrative example of a 70-year-old retiree with $2 million saved who needs $50,000 per year over 30 years. Before inflation, that baseline requires $1.5 million across three decades. If that retiree places the entire portfolio into volatile equities and suffers a 30% market drop in year one, a previously secure retirement suddenly faces serious strain.
Schade explains, “When retirees take an unnecessary market loss right as withdrawals begin, they essentially undergo a procedure they did not need and end up worse off. Retirement is like a flame. At 25, you barely feel the heat, yet as you near retirement and markets drop, you feel burned.”
To reverse that process, Schade advocates running a stability calculation before discussing investment products. Rather than plugging an assumed 7% growth rate into planning software, savers and advisors should test a zero-return baseline first and solve backward for the exact annual return required to fund retirement expenses. When that required return falls below roughly 5%, conservative savers may be able to meet their goals without exposing essential nest-egg funds to stock market downturns.
In those scenarios, principal-protected strategies such as fixed indexed annuities or lifetime income riders can serve as a foundation. These tools are designed to protect principal against stock market losses, backed by the claims-paying ability and financial reserves of the issuing insurance carrier, in exchange for capping maximum market upside. Schade notes that in his 24 years of practice, roughly 85% of incoming clients had never been shown how principal-protected insurance strategies trade unlimited upside for downside protection.
“Rather than putting people into vague buckets like conservative or moderate, we should put an exact number on the return they need and find the safest tools to reach it,” Schade notes. “Most retirees do not care about chasing 15% in a bull market if they can earn 5% or 6% without watching their savings drop in a crash.”
Before accepting portfolio volatility, savers should make running a required-return calculation a standard first step in retirement planning. When retirement plans are built around required stability rather than benchmark outperformance, conservative retirees avoid the worst-case scenario of returning to work after a downturn. Measuring financial advice by certainty and peace of mind rather than bull-market speculation leaves savers with a clearer question before accepting volatility. If someone has already saved enough to fund the life desired, why risk blowing it up for extra return never needed?


